Skip to main content

New system under development to assess complications in urological surgery

20.11.2026

An international research team, including Assist. Prof. Gökhan Çalık from the Department of Urology at Istanbul Medipol University School of Medicine, has compiled records of 130,034 urological surgeries performed at 180 hospitals across 33 countries. The study, known as CAMUS, aims to establish standardized criteria for recording complications arising during and after surgery, while also incorporating assessments of how these complications affect patients’ daily lives.

Araştırma Makale Haberi


Recovery from surgery continues long after a patient has been discharged from the hospital. Persistent pain, fatigue, or urinary incontinence can affect daily life even when these problems do not require further medical intervention. Moreover, several complications that appear relatively minor in isolation can collectively make recovery more difficult. How, then, can these effects be taken into account when evaluating a patient’s postoperative experience?

The CAMUS initiative, which includes Assist. Prof. Gökhan Çalık from the Department of Urology at Istanbul Medipol University School of Medicine among its contributing researchers, seeks to address this question through a standardized system for recording and evaluating surgical complications. The international team’s research protocol, published in European Urology Open Science under the title“The CAMUS Initiative: A Multiphase, Multicentre International Collaboration to Redefine Risk Stratification, Reporting, and Grading of Surgical Complications in Urology”, outlines a seven-phase program to improve how complications occurring during and after urological surgery are documented, how their severity is assessed, and how surgical risks are predicted. As a research protocol, the article describes the study’s methodology and planned next steps rather than reporting the final results of the initiative.

WHY DO REPORTED COMPLICATION RATES DIFFER FOR THE SAME SURGERY?
The widely used Clavien–Dindo classification grades the severity of postoperative complications according to the treatment required to manage them. The Comprehensive Complication Index, meanwhile, combines multiple complications experienced by an individual patient into a single score. According to the article, these approaches may not adequately capture conditions such as persistent pain, fatigue, or sexual dysfunction, which can significantly affect patients even when no additional treatment is required. Complications occurring during surgery also fall outside the scope of the Clavien–Dindo classification.

Previous studies cited in the article illustrate the challenges of comparing complication records. Following radical cystectomy, a procedure involving the complete removal of the urinary bladder, reported complication rates range from 26% to 86% within the first 30 days and from 30% to 100% within the first 90 days, depending on the study. The researchers note that, alongside factors such as patients’ preoperative health, surgical complexity, and institutional experience, differences in which complications are recorded and how they are documented contribute to this wide variation.

RECORDS OF 130,034 SURGERIES COLLECTED FROM 33 COUNTRIES
In the first phase of the initiative, surgical records were collected from 180 hospitals in 136 cities across 33 countries on six continents. Three centers in Türkiye also contributed data. The resulting dataset comprises records of 130,034 major urological procedures performed between 1978 and 2025, including prostate and bladder removal surgeries, major kidney operations, and procedures involving the removal of lymph nodes from the retroperitoneal region, located behind the abdominal cavity. The authors describe it as the largest international dataset of its kind in urological surgery.

The team compiled information on patients’ preoperative health status, the course of their operations, and complications arising afterward. Data collection has been completed, while analyses are ongoing. Using these records, the researchers will investigate which factors increase the risk of complications and how consistently existing assessment methods perform across different surgical procedures and hospitals. One limitation of this phase is that the information historically documented may vary between institutions.

PHYSICIANS AND NURSES ASSESS WHICH COMPLICATIONS SHOULD BE RECORDED
A total of 1,113 physicians from 57 countries participated in the initial survey. The research team employed the Delphi method, a structured process in which participants provide feedback over multiple survey rounds to establish consensus. Physicians agreed that complications occurring during surgery, recurring afterward, or emerging at a later stage should be documented. There was also support for incorporating problems reported directly by patients into the assessment process.

In a preliminary study involving 20 nurses experienced in urological care, all participants identified a need for a standardized assessment system, while 75% supported adopting the proposed CAMUS system. The nurses emphasized the importance of detecting deterioration in patients’ conditions at an early stage and documenting nursing care interventions that do not require physician involvement. Wound-related problems and urinary incontinence were highlighted as complications that can affect quality of life. The researchers plan to expand the survey to include more nurses from different countries in subsequent phases.

NEW SYSTEM TO BE TESTED WITH MORE THAN 2,000 PATIENTS
The researchers plan to ask patients undergoing urological surgery about difficulties involving urinary continence, sexual function, digestion, and other aspects of their health, as well as the extent to which these problems affect their daily lives. The responses will inform the development of a scoring system that integrates patients’ experiences with assessments made by healthcare professionals. The team is also developing a tool to help predict surgical complexity and the risk of complications during or after surgery.

The proposed digital system will allow each complication experienced by a patient to be recorded separately, together with its time of onset and the treatment or care provided. Patient-reported outcomes will also be incorporated into the same record.

The team aims to test the system with more than 2,000 newly enrolled patients. This phase will assess the completeness of complication records, the consistency with which healthcare professionals evaluate the same complications, and how accurately the system reflects problems reported by patients.

STUDY PROPOSES A NEW FRAMEWORK FOR ASSESSING SURGICAL COMPLICATIONS
The CAMUS initiative’s distinctive contribution to the scientific literature lies in combining an extensive international surgical dataset with the perspectives of physicians and nurses while proposing a framework that also incorporates patients’ experiences. This approach would allow complications to be assessed not only according to when they occur and what interventions they require, but also in terms of their combined impact on patients’ daily lives.

If the system demonstrates reliable performance during the planned patient follow-up phase, it could provide a standardized basis for comparing surgical outcomes across hospitals. It could also help clinicians provide patients with more comprehensive information before surgery, including how potential complications may affect their recovery and everyday activities.

Last Update : 20/11/2026 - 16:41



Knowledge / Support Button